Cover image for Islam and liberal citizenship : the search for an overlapping consensus
Islam and liberal citizenship : the search for an overlapping consensus
March, Andrew F., 1976-

Personal Author:
Publication Information:
New York ; Oxford : Oxford University Press, 2009.
Physical Description:
x, 350 pages ; 25 cm


Material Type
Item Barcode
Call Number
Shelf Location
Item Holds
Book 0343794 KBP2430 .M37 2009 Central Campus Library

On Order



How can Muslims be both good citizens of liberal democracies and good Muslims? This is among the most pressing questions of our time, particularly in contemporary Europe. Some argue that Muslims have no tradition of separation of church and state and therefore can't participate in secular,pluralist society. At the other extreme, some Muslims argue that it is the duty of all believers to resist Western forms of government and to impose Islamic law.Andrew F. March is seeking to find a middle way between these poles. Is there, he asks, a tradition that is both consistent with orthodox Sunni Islam that is also compatible with modern liberal democracy? He begins with Rawls's theory that liberal societies rely for stability on an ''overlappingconsensus'' between a public conception of justice and popular religious doctrines and asks what kinds of demands liberal societies place on citizens, and particularly on Muslims.March then offers a thorough examination of Islamic sources and current trends in Islamic thought to see whether there can indeed be a consensus. March finds that the answer is an emphatic ''yes.'' He demonstrates that there are very strong and authentically Islamic arguments for accepting thedemands of citizenship in a liberal democracy, many of them found even in medieval works of Islamic jurisprudence. In fact, he shows, it is precisely the fact that Rawlsian political liberalism makes no claims to metaphysical truth that makes it appealing to Muslims.

Table of Contents

Introduction: Moral Conflict, Political Liberalism, and Islamic Ethics
Part I Justificatory Comparative Political Theory: The Search for Overlapping Consensus through ''Conjecture,''
1 Purposes: The Place of Justificatory Comparative Political Theory
2 Methods: The Ethics of Comparative Ethics
Part II Islam and Liberal Citizenship: Patterns of Moral Disagreement and Principled Reconciliation
3 Islamic Objections to Citizenship in Non-Muslim Liberal Democracies
4 Identifying Equilibrium: An Ideal-Typical Islamic Doctrine of Citizenship
Part III Islamic Affirmations of Liberal Citizenship
5 Residence in a Non-Muslim State
6 Loyalty to a Non-Muslim State
7 Recognition of Non-Muslims and Moral Pluralism
8 Solidarity with Non-Muslims
Conclusion: Tradition and Creativity in Grounding Moral Obligation to Non-Muslims